Calling for a “Contemporary Worship Music” Revolution: Part 4, I Wanna Cross Over: The Struggle for Mainstream Legitimacy

In the last forty years there have been very few notable pop-gospel artists who have been strong enough to build a mainstream audience.

In Australia we had the first million record selling chart album with the singing nun, Sister Janet Mead, who was a one hit wonder with her electrified rendition of The Lord’s Prayer.  While Mead’s Holy Orders were a significant novelty factor, she did not keep attracting non-church audiences past that song.

In contrast, perhaps my favourite 1970s gospel artist who did draw worldwide attention is Andraé Crouch – especially when he was with his band The Disciples.

Andraé Crouch and the Disciples

In albums such as Keep on Singin’ (1972), Take Me Back (1975), and This is Another Day (1976), Crouch fused traditional Gospel with soul, funk and folk rock to get a sound that had emotional guts and artistic brilliance.  Crouch is the real deal.  His performing career started in 1960 with the Church of God in Christ Singers which included everyone’s hammond player of choice, Billy Preston.  But when he formed the Disciples in 1965 they elevated to such heights of popularity as to find themselves performing on Johnny Carson and at Carnegie Hall.  Crouch went on to collaborate with Quincy Jones, Paul Simon, Michael Jackson and Madonna and even had Elvis Presley perform one his compositions ‘I’ve Got Confidence.’  Andraé Crouch is living proof that gospel artists that are truly great musicians can be appreciated for their talent by the mainstream: his songs still get sung in churches (mainly in America).

More recently there have been many gospel artists find chart success in USA.  Bands and solo artists such as dc Talk, Lecrae, RED, Casting Crowns and the David Crowder Band have debuted in the top ten, but temporary chart success does not necessarily mean that the music is finding the mainstream.  When Christians purchase these albums all at the same time, (such as at a conference) the sales will register high on the charts for a week but quickly drop down the following week.  This phenomena occurs annually in the Australian charts.  The Sydney Morning Herald explains it (July 11, 2011),

Beyonce and Lady Gaga may lay claim to some of the biggest audiences worldwide, but Australia’s Hillsong Church has bumped off both pop powerhouses to score a top three berth on the ARIA albums chart.

Their latest album God Is Able, released to coincide with the annual Hillsong conference, debuted at number three this week, entering ahead of Beyonce’s 4 and Lady Gaga’s Born This Way, which stand at fourth and fifth respectively.

It is the 10th Christian record to reach the top 10 since 2002.

The fact is, in the last thirty years, the only musicians singing about Jesus to consistently draw a mainstream audience have been those singing in traditional gospel (The Blind Boys of Alabama and Mavis Staplesor classical styles.  While Andraé Crouch’s pop-gospel did wow the world, not many others have done likewise.

In my next entry I will write about the great secular artists who found Jesus, the many who flirted with Jesus.

2 thoughts on “Calling for a “Contemporary Worship Music” Revolution: Part 4, I Wanna Cross Over: The Struggle for Mainstream Legitimacy

  1. Serious question Peter, Why does Christian music need mainstream legitimacy? Few non-believers embrace Christian preaching so I am not sure why music that often struggles with the Christian journey, elevates the Christian God, speaks (unsurprisingly) in terms that are often intended for Christians should find it’s legitimacy in a secular embrace.

    Sure there could/should be music that speaks from a Christian about real human struggles but Christian expression is often not a universal concern.

    Hear me right, all humanity has certain struggles, concerns and celebrations but many of the concerns and struggles of broad humanity are readjusted due to the cross because of the eternal hope it provides even in the storm.

    BTW – enjoying your blogs – Josh

    • Hey Josh,
      Thanks for the question. It’s not that I think Christian music has to have mainstream legitimacy to have worth. However, I am trying to do two things (1) make an observation of a major shift in church music history and asking “WHAT’S HAPPENED??”(2) and also I’m sharing my conviction that Christian musicians have the capacity to create truly great music that communicates and celebrates the glory and mystery of the gospel.

      Unfortunately great Christian musicians that do come along feel they have to sing about girls and being depressed and disguise their faith (like Mumford and Sons or Australian band Evermore). I don’t think Christian artists have to always make art that has a faith theme, but they should sometimes want to.

      Perhaps all of this is a byproduct of the ‘juvenilization’ of the western church?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s